Friday, July 12, 2013

Americans Exercising More, But Not Weighing Less and Other Health News

This has been going around all day yesterday in different publications, but honestly I think over the years our sense of what we are supposed to know about weight loss has been warped.

Americans may be reportedly exercising more, but they're still eating like crap. To lose weight, the most important component is diet. And it's not as simple as "calories in/calories out."  If it were, the weight loss companies would go out of business.

Recently, the CDC admitted that there were no adverse health risks from eating too much salt. Maybe we can get the USDA out of the business of giving us dietary advice and admit that 300g of carbs a day is way too much.

Speaking of which, The Atlantic has a dumb, overly long article titled "How Junk Food Can End Obesity." The author's main points seem to be the following:

1) Those who believe in promoting "real food" are wrong because it's not sustainable in the long run.
2) Poor people can't afford real food, so their only hope is processed.
3) Those who object to processed food only are only objecting to the fact that it's processed.
4) Real food also contains fat and carbs, so why bother?

And to each of these points, I say the following:

1) People need education on what's good for them in their diet.  and I think it can be sustainable.  You don't necessarily have to go organic, but just making wiser choices will go a long way towards better health.
2) You don't have to go organic to eat "real" food.  Right now, I can't buy grass fed beef because I can't afford it, but it doesn't prevent me from buying a steak when it goes on sale.  Better choices will go a long way towards your goals.
3) I object to processed foods because most of it has wheat in it (which I no longer eat) and because of the number of carbs in the food.  Because I'm diabetic, I can't even purchase "gluten-free" baking kits because they replace the wheat with starch, which is also a no-no.
4) He likes to demonize fat in the article, whereas I welcome the fat in my diet because it's one of the keys to me losing weight. The author is using outdated information on calories and fat to make his arguments, which is unfortunate.

Thankfully a lot of the comments on the article call him out on his cherrypicking of facts and outright misinformation.  Processed foods are not the answer, no matter who tries to tell you differently.

No comments:

Post a Comment